Tag Archives: personal rhetoric

Our (Un?)Natural Transparency

The skill of “reading” each other turns out to be one of the crucial markers of a person’s social intelligence. State-of-mind inferences we make about others are what make rich connections possible. 

In a lifetime of studying human rhetoric, one short passage from master rhetorician and theorist Richard Weaver has stayed with me. It is a thought that for me has turned into an intellectual anchor. In a brief summation of one of his articles focusing on political argument he wrote that “style in speech always causes one to be a marked man.” His point was that we give ourselves away, especially our political tendencies, in the specific ways we shape our ideas. Even lies can be indicative of a person’s state of mind. The more Donald Trump claims he “always” draws big crowds, the more observers are justified in concluding that he measures his self-worth in attention from others. His rhetoric gives him away.

second thoughts

In a piece almost ten years ago I argued a version of this point that a person’s inner state of mind can be estimated from even a modest sample of their everyday rhetoric. I called the piece “Finding Interiority,” claiming that a person’s routine language offers a window into their thinking. We are the species that ponders, muses, worries, fears, hopes and ruminates. Those states of mind easily surface and give us important clues. Indeed, most of us find it hard to conceal what is going on inside. The result is that we routinely construct our responses to others based on the intentions and feelings that show up in their rhetoric.

Not surprisingly, our skill at “reading” each other turns out to be one of the crucial markers of social intelligence. Our estimates of another’s needs usually allow us to meet them at least halfway. These efforts to know another at least a little are a useful reminder of how much we depend upon what psychologists sometimes call “theory of mind,” which is another way of describing the skill of inferring mental states of others. The trigger is almost always our statements and their accompanying physical expressions: even simple cues like frowns or smiles. Inferred needs and aspirations quickly make others around us less than strangers. Does Donald Trump not notice that his words so obviously reveal his needs and fears?  We notice what his rhetoric signifies, not what it says. But he seems to be a captive of the surfaces of thought. For thousands of years we have more or less operated under the assumption expressed in Hebrew and Christian texts that ‘what a person thinks in his heart, so he is’  (Book of Proverbs 23:7).

 Actor Matt Damon in The Talented Mr. Ripley (1999)

But are we really so cognitively naked? Not always. And the exceptions are just as interesting. In the character of Tom Ripley, Patricia Highsmith reminds us what is at stake if a person manages to pull off a total deception of benign intent. Under the cover of a seemingly pleasant personality, her character schemed to murder a wealthy “friend” to inherit his lush life. We may be wired to make estimates of another’s state of mind based on almost anything they say, but we can still get it wrong by marrying the wrong person, buying a salesperson’s deceptive pitch, or being deceived by a new employer.

The risk of misreading another is one reason we are drawn to plays and actors who professionally manipulate the tools of psychic exposure. The first two acts of a play or film typically give us hints of character usually not noticed by other players. And so the final act sorts things out in ways an audience has begun to anticipate.  The play could be Edward Albee’s searing Who’s Afraid of Virginia Wolfe, Arthur Miller’s The Death of a Salesman, or a docudrama about the fraudulent science of Elizabeth Theranos. 

When we Claim Authorship for Words that are not Our Own

There are some additional challenges to Weaver’s conclusion that we are  easily “read.”  Most high-functioning adults have learned to build at least a partial screen of privacy. Friends can surprise us with unanticipated feelings or reactions. Profound depression and even suicide can come as a shock to friends who had no idea that a person was in deep despair.

And now a new wrinkle. We need to wonder who is the real author of a person’s words. What if I don’t have to use my own personal lexicon and experiences to communicate thoughts? Can’t A.I. do the task as well, offering some generic approximation of our ideas?  I was recently in conversation with a lawyer who marveled at the time he was saving by using A.I. in his correspondence. I responded that those thoughts on the page weren’t his. He should insist on using his own words. “No matter,” was the reply. The A.I. version was close enough.

Granted, lawyers deal with a lot of boilerplate communication, which is why men are often asked in questionnaires if they are pregnant.  But I worry that we are raising generations who will be unprepared to engage in the invention of expressive ideas. The act of writing or speaking our thoughts requires the mental effort–full invention–to find the right ways to give voice to our beliefs and concerns. Language stripped of the nuances of individuality may work, but badly and more or less like customer-service chatbots. We allow ourselves to become mute when other people or machines begin to speak on our behalf.  Giving up our rights of personal authorship should matter.

It is a core part of our nature to carry signs of our uniqueness in the thoughts and expressions we favor. When it is even possible, rhetorical camouflage is not a help to others or ourselves.

red white blue bar

A Linguistic Habit We Should Toss

“Biased?” Of Course. We are not capable of neutral observation. Human perception is an instrument of approximation powered by personal experience. It follows that our rhetoric always has ‘tendency:’ personal, political or social. It cannot be otherwise. 

There are many words in our language that have outlived their usefulness, but none more so than that old standby, “biased.” We hear it all the time. ‘People are “biased;’ ‘The story was biased;’ ‘The research has a built-in bias;’ ‘His attitude shows a bias;’ and so on. Someone recently reminded me that another project I am working on is “biased toward the 12-tone system of music.” (Guilty, obviously, but annoyed and unrepentant.) And, of course, a given news outlet is said to be “biased” toward Republicans and another one is biased toward liberals. In any conversation about media, the use of the term can take off like popcorn in a hot pan. And, given the lack of precision that usually comes with the ways it is tossed out, its only one more step to note that the ocean has a bias to flood low shore towns, or that dry forests have a bias toward burning. In the interests of full disclosure, I also have a bias toward food. Can’t kick it and won’t try.

The point of all of this is that the term is mostly an empty word being used as an observation. Even if the term was nailed to the floor in the middle of a room with a spotlight overhead and encircled by a velvet museum rope, I’d still wrench it out and toss it in the trash.  It has gotten to be that irritating as an ostensible insight.

The obvious point is that we are never neutral observers. Humans are not measurement instruments. Human rhetoric always has tendency: personal, political, linguistic, or cultural. It cannot be otherwise. There is simply no way to excise bias from humans using ordinary language and preferred behaviors. We can design instruments for precision.  But, except for mathematicians, its not a value we usually emulate.

The problem here is that the user of the term presumes a purer version of events. But even this presumption has a problem.

Since even hard “data” rarely speaks for itself, we must narrate its meaning in ways that justifiably skew in various possible directions. My office thermometer tells me that is 50 degrees outside. But I’m a member of the jabbering species, so I might interpret this simple data to a friend as a “warm” early spring day. That’s a judgment made in relation to the fact that I’m in the northeast, not balmy Sarasota.

The term “biased” is also used as a blunt instrument of dismissal. There is little going on behind the remark other than the obvious point that someone’s narrative doesn’t match another’s preferred narrative.

This means there is nearly always one simple answer to another’s charge of bias. It is a straightforward “of course,” with an addendum: “Could it be otherwise?”

All of this suggests it would be more intellectually honest to not hide behind this one word.  Go ahead and explain the specific attitude or behavior that is bothersome or seems wide of the mark.